Hiring is a delicate and intricate process, and one of the most challenging aspects is rejecting candidates. While it may not be the most pleasant task, providing constructive and respectful feedback to candidates who are not selected is crucial for maintaining a positive employer brand and fostering a culture of professionalism.
In this Top Echelon Software blog post, we will explore tips for rejecting a job candidate that not only ensure a positive candidate experience, but also contribute to building a strong employer reputation.
Tips on how to reject a job applicant
Rejecting a candidate may not be the most enjoyable aspect of the end-to-end recruitment process, but it is an unavoidable step. While you might receive numerous job applications, only one person will ultimately receive the job offer. It’s crucial to acquire the skills necessary to gracefully decline the multitude of applicants.
Navigating job rejection is a sensitive matter. Utilize the following five must-have tips for rejecting a job applicant:
1. Don’t ignore applicants you don’t plan to interview
The influx of job applications can be daunting to handle. The initial step, before presenting candidates to your client, involves the challenging task of narrowing down the pool. Streamlining this process is made more manageable by leveraging an applicant tracking system (ATS) to parse resumes and organize applicants in order of relevance, from most to least applicable.
The application process can be time-consuming and emotionally draining for candidates. Ignoring applicants you don’t plan to interview can be detrimental to your company’s reputation and the candidate’s overall experience. Even if a candidate doesn’t meet the qualifications or requirements for the role, acknowledging their effort and time by sending a polite rejection email can go a long way.
Ignoring candidates may lead to negative reviews on employer review sites, social media, and other platforms, potentially dissuading other qualified candidates from applying in the future. Furthermore, in today’s interconnected world, news about a company’s lack of courtesy can spread rapidly, tarnishing the company’s image and affecting its ability to attract top talent.
2. Avoid overpromising
During the hiring process, it’s essential to avoid making promises that cannot be fulfilled. Overpromising, whether intentional or not, can create unrealistic expectations for candidates and lead to disappointment upon rejection. Be transparent about the company’s expectations and the candidate’s fit within the organization.
If a candidate asks about specific aspects of the job or company culture, provide honest and realistic answers. For example, if there are limitations on career advancement or if the work environment is fast-paced and demanding, it’s better to communicate this early on. This transparency ensures that candidates have a clear understanding of what to expect, reducing the likelihood of misconceptions and disappointment in the future.
3. Follow-up with candidates throughout process
Communication is key at every stage of the hiring process, including rejection. Keep candidates informed about their status in the process, even if it means delivering the news that they will not be moving forward. Timely and clear communication can help candidates manage their expectations and plan their next steps.
Consider providing constructive feedback, such as areas where the candidate excelled and areas that may need improvement. This feedback not only helps candidates understand the reasons behind their rejection but also provides valuable insights for their future job searches. However, it’s crucial to strike a balance, delivering feedback in a constructive and respectful manner to avoid causing unnecessary distress.
4. Decide between email and phone rejections
Choosing between email and phone rejections depends on various factors, including the candidate’s preferences, the nature of the position, and the level of personalization required. Both methods have their advantages and drawbacks, so it’s essential to carefully consider which approach aligns with your company culture and values.
Email rejections are often seen as more efficient, allowing candidates to process the information at their own pace. This method also provides a written record of the communication. However, email rejections can come across as impersonal, especially if they are generic and lack personalized feedback.
Crafting a job rejection email doesn’t need to lack a personal touch. While it’s convenient to use your ATS software for mass rejection emails, make an effort to personalize each one by addressing the candidate by name. Avoid generic salutations like “Dear Applicant.” Additionally, if you express a desire to stay in touch, ensure that it is a genuine sentiment rather than a mere formality.
On the other hand, phone rejections allow for a more personal touch, demonstrating empathy and sincerity. A phone call enables candidates to ask questions and seek clarification, providing a more human experience. However, phone rejections can be time-consuming, and if not handled delicately, they may inadvertently cause additional stress for the candidate.
Ultimately, the decision between email and phone rejections should be made based on the individual circumstances of each hiring process. Some companies may choose to combine both methods, sending an initial email and following up with a phone call if the candidate requests further discussion.
5. Maintain future communication
Rejection doesn’t have to be the end of the relationship between the candidate and the company. Maintaining future communication can be beneficial for both parties. Candidates who receive respectful and considerate rejections are more likely to view the company positively, even if they weren’t selected for the current role.
Consider inviting rejected candidates to join the company’s talent network or subscribe to newsletters and job alerts. This way, they remain engaged with the company and may be interested in future opportunities. In addition, periodically reaching out to rejected candidates with relevant updates or industry insights demonstrates that the company values its talent pool and fosters a sense of community.
While a candidate may not be an ideal match for the current position, it doesn’t automatically disqualify them from consideration for future job openings. Save their details in your ATS software for recruitment agencies and consider reaching out if their skills align with a future opportunity.
Furthermore, you have the option to recommend candidates from your pool to other recruiters. If you engage in split placements with fellow recruiters, share the candidate’s information with them for potential collaboration.